Sunday, January 1, 2012

BOOK VS MOVIE: To Kill a Mockingbird

With the releases of Harper Lee's sole novel To Kill a Mockingbird and Robert Mulligan's film, they raised questions about one's beliefs towards race. Also bear in mind both were released at the beginning of the civil rights movement.

The fact that it's told from a child's point of view gives the audience a sense of naivete. Scout, the narrator, is as unclear of the many events in Maycomb as much as the audience. Apart from the folklore surrounding him, no one knows much about Boo Radley. Scout, as well as us, barely knows of the case her father Atticus is defending in until the actual trial.

That's what makes Lee's writing so effective. We learn of major points in the story when Scout learns of them. And if you're wondering about the significance of the title, Atticus mentions that "it's a sin to kill a mockingbird." (Mockingbirds are mentioned as symbolism for innocence.)

Mulligan's film is just as great as Lee's novel. There are only a few minor changes, but Horton Foote's script stays true to what Lee originally wrote. You just can't imagine anyone else but Gregory Peck as Atticus Finch. Seriously, you just can't.

Now comes the challenge of choosing which is better. It's really hard to say, even with a metaphorical gun to my head. In all honesty, I just can't. Both the novel and the film have their own certain qualities, hence the challenge.

What's worth checking out?: I'd go with both.


  1. I haven't read the novel so I can't comment on that, but totally agree with your statement: "You just can't imagine anyone else but Gregory Peck as Atticus Finch. Seriously, you just can't." I read on his bio that this is his favorite role, and some reviewers have said that Atticus is when the 'role and the actor meets' Is it any wonder I LOVE that guy!!

  2. Both are great. Lee's resonate novel wins though.

    Great write up.

  3. I haven't read the novel, and the last time I saw the film was years ago - time for a re-watch I think! Great write up Anna :)

  4. Both are equally Great!! One of the very few films I consider at par with the book and exactly for the reason you stated - it mostly stays true to the Novel.


Comments are appreciated. More so if they are appropriate.